by A.Jathindra
I still remember that day clearly, Mr.Makendraraja allies Mathiah, the second leader of LTTE was visiting Thampalagamam; which is my native village in 1990. The people honoured and welcomed him with the traditional Hindu ritual at each and every house. I also placed a Pottu (Round mark on the forehead) on his forehead in front of my house when cour turn came. I was 14 years old when this was happening. I never heard about Tamil Nationalism and Liberation struggle or even such as words during that time.

Prabaharan, Yogi and Makendraraja ~ file pic: courtesy: Tehelka
Prabaharan, Yogi and Makendraraja ~ file pic: courtesy: Tehelka
Later I was surprised when it was said that Mathiah was a Traitor. I asked myself how that was possible ? I don’t know what really happened in the LTTE’s jungle even now but I heard later that LTTE had announced that Mathia was close to India’s Research and Analyzing Wing (RAW) and that he attempted to conspire against LTTE.
Actually I wouldn’t want to talk about Mathaih and his politics now, but only remembered how the situation changed in my younger days. Adele Balasingam, has described, about the case of Mathiah, what he did and what was happening at the time in her book - The Will to Freedom (In Tamil Suthanthira Veadkai)
I think that the word Traitor is a most popular word like Tamil Nationalism and Liberation, within the Tamil political environment.
In the earlier phase of Tamil politics, Mr.Appapillai Amirthalingam the Tamil prominent democratic leader had used the Traitor word against their political opponents, who criticized TULF and its political journey.
Later LTTE has adopted this word – Traitor;Not only LTTE but all arms based groups like EPRLF, PLOTE, TELO and EROS adopted this word as fascinating tool for use against their opposition groups.
The LTTE was the only group which used this word against their proclaimed enemies very tactically and overwhelmingly. In the LTTE’s mandate intellectuals, journalist, writers and activists were all Traitors if they criticized or opposed them. Many of the Tamil intellectuals left the country or became so quiet and stopped involvement in public life.
Still the word Traitor is a very attractive word to marginalize the alternative viewpoints in the Tamil political platform by the so-called Tamil Nationalists. The Tamil Diaspora has been splitting based on this words after end of the LTTE story in Sri Lanka. In my view, the word Traitor is political capital for sympathizers of LTTE among Tamil Diaspora at present.
We couldn’t see any political honesty and any other respective manner on alternative views there even after sixty years of political experiences. Even now the word is used to insult those who are talking about need for meaningful political approaches and meaningful dialogue based on the ground situation.
There is another interesting point about the Tamil Marxists. The above situation I mentioned are based on arms groups but this is very different. This group is something different and they will not use this word as Traitor but they use CIA or RAW instead of Traitor, if somebody criticized their political thought. In my knowledge there is no any influential Marxist group in North and East and also among Tamil Diaspora.
Only one group has been doing something by the name of Neo- democracy with few old people in Colombo. This group has been saying that we need to organize our people for mass revolution like Nepal. Some Diasporas also support to this tip of old people as sympathizers of Maoism.
The concept of Neo- Democracy was mad by Chairman Mao Ze Dong but it was premature when Mao moved close to the Nixon government of US. China has also abandoned this idea since 1984, the People daily the Chinese official paper said clearly that the Marxism is a great thing but if we are going to follow this continually then we will be isolated from the Neo-world order.
But now few foolish people are talking about this old type of thinking pattern. Actually this type of groups are trying to mislead the people especially younger generation of Tamil society.
Recently I wrote an article about India at one of the Tamil Diaspora’s web then this type of stupid people criticized me saying t he is a Traitor. I was criticized for saying very frankly that LTTE had made a big mistake regarding India and finally India has lost her young leader.
Now very interesting things are going on based on words regarding Traitor currently. The Tamil Diaspora is having “ first night” with Traitors. The Diaspora, are collapsed themselves as investors in the LTTE after the debacle . The whole Tamil Diaspora is not sympathetic with LTTE’s idea but few hard liners there are active still; they are using this word against others who are talking about meaningful political settlement.
Another group functioning is the so-called Transnational Government; they have selected a prime minister also recently. One LTTE group is led by Nediayavan & Jayachandra who is running Tamil net, the LTTE’s media.
Transnational Government is led by Uruthirakumaran, based in US. Another third party also is trying to establish a set up through KP. I know some Diaspora activists have realized the situation and are willing to work with KPs’ line but they fear the hardliners.
I read KP’s recent interviews at www.dbsjeyaraj.com . I think that KP is right and he realizes the situation clearly but some hardcore LTTE says KP is traitor. I was thinking that who will be deciding about Traitor? Who is able to decide that?
I have raised this question myself many times when I come across this word normally. I think that those who use this word against others will be thinking about their own political benefit always.Therefore If someone opposed their political path they say those are Traitors. This is the basic history of the word of Traitors in the Tamil environment.
Now the Tamil people needs meaningful political approach and build up a good relationship with the current regime. We cant live in past history always.
The LTTE’s ideology which is based on creating enemies always. They have been creating their enemy themselves always since their birth, if they can’t accuse any one as enemy they can’t do any things. Still few hardcore LTTE ‘ers who are surviving in European countries are doing this but they are not able to do any thing for Tamil people who are affected by war.
The world is changing we also need to change but few Diasporas never ready to listen this. This is their problem too now.
One interesting question is there, that is who wants to become a Traitor, who is willing to join the team of Traitors?
The answers are very easy. Just say or write these sentences. “We need to have meaningful political approach . We need to have proper working mechanism therefore we need to talk with the government of Sri Lanka. We must consider on our affected people which is the first priority issue at this juncture.
If you say or write these lines in a few days you will instantly become a prominent Traitor in the Tamil world.

I am fully accepting your explanation.When Mr.Alfred Durayappah was Mp and Mayor of Jaffna who made Jaffna a model city was supprting the SLFP and started to promote SLFP.The Federal Party and others branded him as traitor.The same people the next day come to his house for favours.If the tamil community would have supprted him we the Tamils would not have been in this situation
ReplyDeleteI aws in Srilanka for 6weeks and went to Jaffna and mingled with the people and
the feed back in Town was about him.Why are the expatriates still trying to ruin the life of innocent civilians who are happy for their own glory by issying visiting cards with Ministerial designation From the Government on Exile.
Canadian Citizen
Posted by: Canadian Citizen | November 29, 2010 07:56 AM
May 9, 2011 12:38 AM
I am fully accepting your explanation.When Mr.Alfred Durayappah was Mp and Mayor of Jaffna who made Jaffna a model city was supprting the SLFP and started to promote SLFP.The Federal Party and others branded him as traitor.The same people the next day come to his house for favours.If the tamil community would have supprted him we the Tamils would not have been in this situation
ReplyDeleteI aws in Srilanka for 6weeks and went to Jaffna and mingled with the people and
the feed back in Town was about him.Why are the expatriates still trying to ruin the life of innocent civilians who are happy for their own glory by issying visiting cards with Ministerial designation From the Government on Exile.
Canadian Citizen
Posted by: Canadian Citizen | November 29, 2010 07:56 AM
May 9, 2011 12:39 AM
This is the fate of all ARMED REVOLUTIONARY groups in the world!
ReplyDeleteDanton was the revolutionary leader in the French Revolution and was guillotined by the selfsame revolutionaries and branded a Traitor!
Trotsky was the architect of the Red Army and hacked to death by Stalin!
Almost all the Revolutionary leaders who accompanied Lenin while he entering into Russia before Bolshevik Revolution, were either killed or imprisoned by Stalin and branded "anti-revolutionaries!
Liu Shaochi and almost all the Revolutionary leaders in China were either butchered or imprisoned as traitors!
If JVP had won their "revolution" almost all the revolutionary leaders would have been killed in the name of Sri Lankan Revolution!
If Trotsky himself had taken power in the Soviet Union, he would have done the same thing as Stalin!
Violence begets violence!
This is an eternal truth!
Posted by: Mandawala Hamuduruvo | November 29, 2010 10:17 AM
May 9, 2011 12:40 AM
Dear Jathindra
ReplyDeleteYes, what you have projected are pure facts. If anyone says or writes those words, then they will be stamped as traitors and may be attempted to be eliminated.
From Pandaravannian to Amirthalingham and then to the current comedians, Tamils have behaved like this.
That’s why, my opinion about Tamils: Most Tamils are congenitally imbecile. Tamils do not want to view things on different perspective. My belief and understanding is that I highly appreciate literates to gain knowledge of problem analysis by restructuring it to see it in many different ways. I am a bit concerned on Tamil’s nationalism analysis in SriLanka is too biased towards their usual way of seeing things. We need Tamils to read on Leonardo da Vinci’s theories on problem analysis.
Mathaya is not a traitor; he was the supremo and an intellectual who ranked better than Vellupillai Prabakaran. Rest is self explanatory
Good writing
Regards
Posted by: Sandilyan | November 29, 2010 02:40 PM
May 9, 2011 12:41 AM
The word "traitor" was used as early as 1948 by S.J.V.Chelvanayagam when G. G. Ponnambalam decided to accept D. S. Senanayake's call to join the first UNP cabinet. His administration had a lot of Tamils. His foreign policy, including the Indian citizenship act, was run by Kandiah Vayithiyanathan. His irrigation-colony policies were run by Tamils like Kanagasundaram and Sri Kantha who had a "Ceylonese" vision going beyond an "exclusive enclave for one race".
ReplyDeleteChelva and his followers had a different vision. A vision of driving out the "invaders" from the "Tamil homelands" which will give the crown to a Vellalar. The need to liberate the "exclusive homelands" was already in the Arasu kadchi declarations in 1949. The glory of a Tamil kingdom independent of Colombo was an important theme of the 1952 election but this was rejected as a pipe dream by the Tamil people. The Arasu Kadchi was regarded as a racist extremist party. Thiruchelvan and others preferred the English name "Federal party".
It was the 1956 election campaign which propelled the "sinhala only" politics that provided an opening to the Arasu kadchi to launch civil disobedience programs which led to a strong polarization of the people and made it mainstream.
Taunting the police, being militant and unlawful had been introduced to politics by Marxists as a valid process in extra-parliamentary confrontation.
The Colombo governments successively failed to enforce law and order, when sinhalese thugs began to enter the arena in tandem with the increasingly shrill Arasu Kadchi activism, issuing wooden pistols, Arasu stamps, tar brushing Sinhala signs and SRI-car plates, establishing makkal padai etc..
The label "Traitor" began to be increasingly applied to any moderate Tamil who sought any dialog with the sinhalese. Even the Banda-Chela pact, and the Chleva-Dudly pacts were actually condemned in Jaffna nationalist circles as "treacherous sell outs", and they were appeased by Chelvanayagam saying that "these were tactical first steps towards our final goal".
Surely, the Buddhist monks knew the meaning of the word "Arasu" - a word derived from the sanskrit "Raashta", with the vowel "a" added in front to comply with the grammar of the Tolkaapian (and probabaly also the Sidath sanngara grammar of the Sinhalese). Arasu Kadchi meant the "sovereignty party", and it is no wonder that the Buddhist monks who knew Sanskrit did not trust the Banda-Chlelva pact of the Arasu Kadchi.
But this "Arasu" concept dazzled a lot of people who decided that the end justified the means. Anyone who opposed them, or even engaged in talks with the enemy was a "Traitor". In 1948, S.J. V. Chelva used the word "Traitor" merely as a verbal bullet. But by 1975 there were people ready to eliminate "traitors" like Duraiappah, and later Amirthalingam and his associates etc, etc, with real bullets. Even Thiruchelva and SJVChelva would have suffered the same fate if they had lived a little longer.
When you let the Genie out of the bottle, the Genie will want blood sacrifices before he is atoned! It was the Sinhala-army young men of the south, and the Tamil kids abducted by the LTTE
to make cannon fodder, and all those civilians of all ethnicities who suffered in the war, who became the blood sacrifices to the Genie.
Posted by: Sebastian Rasalingam | November 29, 2010 09:46 PM
May 9, 2011 12:44 AM
Hi Jathindra,
ReplyDelete"1) We need to have meaningful political approach .
2) We need to have proper working mechanism therefore we need to talk with the government of Sri Lanka.
3) We must consider on our affected people which is the first priority issue at this juncture.
I don't think people would say you traitor (I wouldn't) if you say 1, 2 & 3 above.
But do you believe the SL and Indian Government can do / is willing to do anything useful for a meaningful solution to Tamils?
Ofcourse we Tamils should unite and consider what we can do to achieve a meaningful solution...
Another word on traitor; I think Kaakai vanniyan was not a traitor (in your word) and ofcourse Karuna.... but not sure did they achieve anything?.... you could ask, did others achieve anything - ofcourse not, why? because they had the traitors with them.
I am not a supporter of LTTE any way. Please understand the present situation and accept the critisms from others. When you write, different people will have different opinions on you.
Ravi